Last night I finished
THE NOTEBOOK - which didn't take me quite as long as I had expected it to.
Just to let you know, if you haven't read this book before and are interested in reading it, you might not want to read this post!
The overall story is sweet, but doesn't all really fit together. For one thing, at the beginning it is really hard to figure out the point of view - is it Allie (the heroine), is it Noah (the hero), or is it some random mystery person (a stalker peeping in the windows)? I finally figured out that Allie and Noah had "written" that portion of the book together, but the point of view still didn't make any sense to me - who is writing down the story? I don't know....
There were also some great moments - can you figure out what the hero is doing in this sentence? He strummed [the guitar] once, adjusted the tension of two strings, then strummed again. This time it sounded about right... Why couldn't he have just said - Noah tuned his stupid guitar and started to play?
Some of his writing reminded me a lot of when Chester (not his real name) was in seventh grade. At that time, Chester felt that to be a better writer, you needed to use big words. So - he would go to the thesaurus and look for the words that were similar to what he wanted, but were bigger, and therefore much more impressive. Reading THE NOTEBOOK at times felt like reading Chester's writing from seventh grade - but Chester has become an incredibly profound writer now....
Sparks also has run-on sentences that I had to read a number of times before I figured out what the hell he was trying to say. This doesn't make a great novel - it just confuses the reader!
There were a few things that made me a bit perturbed in the story as well. For one, Noah takes Allie on a "romantic" canoe ride after they reconnect. He rows - she watches him row in a canoe. Come on - those things are not very easy to row by yourself. This isn't the part that bothered me though. He canoes her to a lake where there are a ton of Canada geese and Trumpeter swans together. Fine, sort of believable. But then, they row around the lake and she touches the swans. And the swans let her. Really!??! Doesn't he know that swans are actually fairly nasty creatures in real life? Sheesh.
The next thing that bothered me is that Noah reads this story to Allie every day because she is suffering from the late stages of Alzheimer's, which is really quite sad for him. Props to them for moving into a nursing home though. I was a bit worried for a while that they were still going to be living in their "amazing" house. Noah restored it at the beginning of the story, and I'm pretty sure that it is the sight where they first did the nasty. Not the point.
One particular day (coincidentally the day our story takes place) Allie remembers - and tells Noah that she loves him and that she will always love him, even after she forgets him again. I don't know if that can really happen with Alzheimer patients, but I find it highly suspect. THEN, just to make the whole story even gooshier (which isn't a word, I know, but I can't come up with one that describes my feelings), on the night of their forty-ninth anniversary, Noah goes and visits Allie in her room. And guess what? You've got it - SHE REMEMBERS HIM! It was a snort/groan worthy moment.
Also, Sparks sort of disses science and doctors at one point when a nurse tells Noah that she knows why Allie isn't as affected by Alzheimer's as she could be. That's because she and the other nurses understand the power of true love - something she says the doctors don't understand. I did snort out loud when I read that line.
Bottom line: cute story. Not terribly believable, and not horribly written.
I'm waiting for the movie to come in the mail, which I am excited for. Two of my three J's will be happy to know that I am looking forward to watching the movie again. To my third J - I know it will be more absurd than the first time! Yipiee!!
Next book I have the honor of reading: Message in a bottle.